Doyle is a rather poor public speaker. I remembered this because many years ago I attended the "State of the State" address at the capitol here in Madison and it was brutal. Yesterday was about the same. He stuttered a lot and there were a lot of uhs, ehs, erms, and other filler. It is very annoying. Maybe others don't find this distracting, but it bothers me.
After you filter out all of the nonsense, Doyle's talk boiled down to two main points.
- In fighting Wisconsin's massive deficit, he will not cut education. This is not surprising, seeing Doyle's wife is a teacher, and he has always been a slave to the teachers unions.
- Doyle plans on helping the state by trying his best to get in line for Obama's infrastructure money. He mentioned his pipe dream of a Midwest fast train system. This idea has been thrown around for at least 20 years and it pretty nuts if you ask me. Doyle mentioned he would love to see a Chicago to Milwaukee to Madison to the Twin Cities train, with a spur to Green Bay. That is fine and dandy, but nobody I know (and I mean NOBODY) commutes TO these places FROM these places to get to work. I actually knew one guy who drove from Madison to the Western suburbs of Milwaukee for work, but I can't imagine that a high speed rail is going to all of a sudden open the spigot for people who live in Madison to work in Milwaukee. Or vice-versa.
That's it, unfortunately. Everything else Doyle said was fluff or gimmick, typical politician speak.
Next up was Dr. Charles Evans, CEO of the Fed in Chicago. I was really looking forward to his remarks.
Boy was I disappointed. Dr. Evans basically gave a short 30 minute talk in which he described things that happened over the last quarter of last year, such as the meltdowns of Lehman, Bear, AIG and others, and what the Fed did. He also talked a bit about policy right now (he is on the board of the FOMC). I didn't learn a thing. In fact, I would guess that anybody that follows financial news even on a casual basis didn't learn anything. I understand that Evans needs to keep his cards close to the vest on some things, but for a man of this stature to give a speech and not even get to some meat is a bit puzzling to me. Honestly, if you read Bloomberg or Yahoo Financial or the WSJ on a semi-daily basis you knew this speech inside and out. I was very disappointed. There was a short Q and A after the speech, and Evans tap danced quite a bit, almost as if he was acting like a politician. Maybe his position is more political than I realized.
I was glad I went, if not for the speakers, for the conversation at the tables with other business people. That was worth going. The speakers were not.
To sum it up in a few words, this was an afternoon wasted. And I had to walk a block in the blistering -15 cold to boot.
Cross posted at ChicagoBoyz.